The Elf Plush is a limited common toy in Adopt Me! that could only be obtained on the 3rd day of the Advent Calendar during the Christmas Event (2019). It is now unavailable and can only be obtained through trading. When clicked on, the player hugs the plush. Like other plushies, the Elf Plush serves no purpose besides being a cosmetic toy.
The Elf Plush resembles a regular Christmas elf with brown hair and black eyes. It wears a pointy green hat with a red brim, green cloth with a red collar, and red shoes.
- The appearance of the Elf Plush is identical to the appearance of the Elf Ornament.